If you love pizza, Delaware has a lot to offer. You can find different styles and flavors across the state that will satisfy any craving.
This article will guide you through the 10 best pizzerias in Delaware to help you discover your new favorite spot.
Expect a mix of traditional and creative options, each with its own unique twist. These pizzerias highlight local ingredients and showcase the diverse food culture in Delaware.
Whether you prefer classic cheese or gourmet toppings, there’s something for everyone.
1) Pizzeria Mariana
Pizzeria Mariana is known for its authentic wood-fired pizza. The restaurant focuses on quality by using a traditional wood-burning oven, giving pizzas a unique flavor and texture.
You will find a sourdough crust that stands out, thanks to years of perfecting the recipe.
Popular menu items include the Pepperoni Pizza, which features a generous layer of crispy pepperoni. The Margherita Pizza, topped with fresh basil and creamy mozzarella, is another favorite among customers.
In addition to pizza, you can enjoy a selection of gourmet appetizers. The oven-fired Meatballs in tomato sauce and the Garlic Cheesie Bread are great starters that are perfect for sharing.
Run by chef Robbie Jester, Pizzeria Mariana offers a cozy dining environment. You can easily order online directly from their website for a convenient experience.
Rating: 4.6 (642 reviews)
Location: 140 E Cleveland Ave, Newark, DE 19711
Contact: (302) 737-2135
Website: Visit Website
2) Amato’s Woodfired Pizza
At Amato’s Woodfired Pizza, you can enjoy pizzas made in a traditional Italian style. Your meal will be crafted with care, using hand-tossed dough and fresh, all-natural ingredients.
The wood-fired oven adds a unique flavor that sets this place apart.
Each pizza is topped with homemade sauces. This attention to detail ensures that every bite is flavorful and satisfying.
You can expect a classic pizza experience with high-quality ingredients.
Amato’s has built a loyal customer base. Many appreciate the inviting atmosphere and friendly service. It’s a great spot for a casual meal or a night out with friends.
You will also find a variety of options on their menu. Whether you prefer classic toppings or something unique, there’s likely something for everyone.
Rating: 4.5 (1300 reviews)
Location: 6 S Sandusky St, Delaware, OH 43015
Contact: (740) 369-8797
Website: Visit Website
3) Shorty’s
Shorty’s is a popular spot in Delaware known for its tasty pizzas. The restaurant offers both dine-in and carry-out options, making it convenient for any occasion.
You can expect a friendly atmosphere that welcomes families and groups.
The menu features a variety of pizza styles and toppings. Whether you prefer classic cheese or something more adventurous, there is something for everyone.
Each pizza is made with fresh ingredients to ensure great taste.
Shorty’s operates with helpful hours to fit your schedule. They serve dinner on Mondays from 3:00 pm to 9:00 pm and open for lunch from Tuesday to Saturday at 11:00 am. This makes it easy to grab a meal any day of the week.
For a local pizza experience, Shorty’s is a must-visit. Many customers appreciate the balance of quality and service, which keeps them coming back.
Rating: 4.5 (619 reviews)
Location: 554 W Central Ave, Delaware, OH 43015
Contact: (740) 362-5555
Website: Visit Website
4) Mamma Gina Pizza
Mamma Gina Pizza is a family-owned pizzeria in New Castle, Delaware, known for its dedication to fresh ingredients. With over 40 years of experience, they offer a wide range of pizza options.
You can choose from round and square pies, including Neapolitan, deep-dish, and Sicilian styles.
The staff at Mamma Gina takes pride in their craft. They regularly introduce new flavors and specials, ensuring there’s always something exciting to try. You can also find various deals and coupons on their menu.
Convenience is key here. Located in a market, you can shop while waiting for your pizza. Whether you’re in for a meal or prefer pickup and delivery, Mamma Gina makes it easy to enjoy their tasty offerings.
For those who love online ordering, Mamma Gina provides a 5% discount on every order placed through Slice. This makes it even more appealing to try their delicious food.
Rating: 4.7 (412 reviews)
Location: 110 N Dupont Hwy, New Castle, DE 19720
Contact: (302) 328-5845
Website: Visit Website
5) Tony’s Cafe
Tony’s Cafe is a well-loved spot for Italian food in Newark, Delaware. You can enjoy a variety of delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes that come from family traditions.
Each dish aims to capture the authentic taste of Italy.
The café offers a cozy atmosphere, perfect for dining in with family or friends. Many guests appreciate the friendly service and warm environment. It’s an excellent choice for casual meals or special events.
Open from Monday to Thursday, the café serves food until 9:30 PM. On Fridays and Saturdays, they stay open an hour later, giving you more time to enjoy your meal. They also offer catering for larger gatherings, making it easy to share their flavors with others.
If you’re looking for a great Italian dining experience, Tony’s Cafe is a top choice in the area. You’ll find plenty of options to satisfy your cravings.
Rating: 4.7 (708 reviews)
Location: 366 Possum Park Rd, Newark, DE 19711
Contact: (302) 737-2411
Website: Visit Website
6) Mohio Pizza Co.
Mohio Pizza Co. focuses on making great pizza with quality ingredients. Their dough is crafted each morning, using fine flour, water, and a natural yeast starter.
This attention to detail results in a unique, silky dough that serves as the foundation for their pizzas.
The sauce is made from pure crushed tomatoes, adding authentic flavor to every bite. You can choose from a variety of fresh toppings prepared in-house. Each pizza is a blend of flavors that aims to impress.
Located in downtown Delaware, the restaurant has a cozy and stylish setting. You can enjoy your meal with family or friends, whether inside or on the outdoor patio. The atmosphere is relaxed yet refined, making it a great place to unwind.
Their mission is simple: deliver delicious food using elegant combinations of simple ingredients. You will find that every visit promises a quality dining experience.
Rating: 4.6 (251 reviews)
Location: 23 N Sandusky St, Delaware, OH 43015
Contact: (740) 363-9990
Website: Visit Website
7) Nicola Pizza
Nicola Pizza has been a staple in Delaware since 1971. The restaurant started in Rehoboth Beach and has now moved to Lewes. Known for its family atmosphere, this pizzeria values quality and tradition.
One unique offering at Nicola Pizza is the Nic-o-Boli. This stuffed pizza has become a local favorite. It features a blend of three cheeses and fresh ingredients, making it a must-try for anyone visiting.
You will find that Nicola Pizza takes pride in creating a homemade product. They focus on using natural ingredients without animal fats or vegetable oils. This commitment to quality sets them apart from other pizzerias.
Nicola Pizza is open daily at 11 AM and offers a welcoming environment for families and friends. Whether you’re a new customer or returning for more memories, the flavors here will leave a lasting impression.
Rating: 4.5 (3,000 reviews)
Location: 17323 Ocean One Plz, Lewes, DE 19958
Contact: (302) 227-6211
Website: Visit Website
8) Little Anthony’s Pizza
Little Anthony’s Pizza is a popular spot for those who crave delicious pizza. Located in New Castle, this pizzeria serves a variety of classic and specialty pizzas. Fresh ingredients and flavorful recipes make their offerings stand out.
You can enjoy a casual dining experience here. The atmosphere is friendly, making it a great place for families or a quick bite with friends. Many visitors appreciate the staff’s service and the inviting environment.
Besides pizza, they also offer a selection of sides, salads, and desserts. This variety allows you to have a complete meal. Many customers come back for their favorites, making it a local favorite.
You can easily find Little Anthony’s Pizza if you’re in the area, and it’s worth a visit.
Rating: 4.5 (821 reviews)
Location: 287 Christiana Rd # 10, New Castle, DE 19720
Contact: (302) 328-4400
Website: Visit Website
9) Mr. P’s Pizzeria
Mr. P’s Pizzeria offers a wide variety of pizzas cooked in a traditional wood-burning oven. You can expect fresh, hand-tossed dough and a chunky tomato sauce made daily. The toppings are high-quality, providing a delicious experience.
In addition to pizza, the menu includes appetizers, salads, and craft beers. You can find unique items like fried pickles and beer-battered mushrooms. Their wings are popular too, available in different flavors.
Mr. P’s is also cash-only, so plan accordingly. An ATM is available on the premises for your convenience. The pizzeria supports local breweries, offering a selection of craft beers on tap.
You can enjoy dining in or take your order to go for a cozy night at home.
Rating: 4.5 (869 reviews)
Location: 1004 Kings Hwy, Lewes, DE 19958
Contact: (302) 645-1900
Website: Visit Website
10) Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria
Dom’s NY Style Pizzeria offers a taste of New York right in Delaware. This pizzeria is known for its classic pizza varieties, including thin crust and fresh toppings.
You can enjoy a casual dining experience or take your meal to go.
The pizzeria has convenient business hours throughout the week. You can order online for a quick pickup or delivery.
The friendly staff aims to provide a pleasant experience for every customer.
With a solid reputation, many visitors recommend this spot for both locals and tourists. Whether you’re craving a slice or a whole pie, Dom’s knows how to satisfy your pizza cravings.
Rating: 4.4 (767 reviews)
Location: 218 W Market St, Wilmington, DE 19804
Contact: (302) 998-7154
Website: Visit Website