Wisconsin is known for its diverse food scene, and pizza is a beloved favorite for many. You might be surprised by the variety and quality of pizzerias available in the state.
In this article, you will discover the 10 best pizzerias in Wisconsin that offer delicious options and unique styles.
From classic thin crust to deep-dish delights, there is something for every pizza lover.
Whether you prefer a quick slice on the go or a sit-down meal with friends, Wisconsin’s pizzerias have you covered.
Prepare to explore some of the top spots for pizza that will satisfy your cravings.
1) San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana
Source: San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana Instagram
San Giorgio Pizzeria Napoletana focuses on making authentic Neapolitan pizza. The pizza dough is prepared fresh and naturally fermented according to strict Italian standards.
This attention to detail ensures that you enjoy high-quality pizza.
The pizzas are cooked in a wood-fired oven at a temperature of 900°F. This heat creates a light and fluffy crust, with a soft center that many pizza lovers appreciate.
The cooking time is quick, usually between 70 to 90 seconds.
You can visit this pizzeria Tuesday through Saturday during dinner hours. The head chef, Gino Fazzari, leads the team in crafting delicious pizzas using time-honored techniques.
If you’re in the Milwaukee area and craving authentic Neapolitan pizza, San Giorgio is a great choice.
Rating: 4.7 (799 reviews)
Location: 838 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Contact: (414) 276-2876
Website: Visit Website
2) Il Ritrovo
Source: Il Ritrovo Instagram
Il Ritrovo is known for its authentic Neapolitan pizza. This pizzeria has a wood fire oven that adds a unique flavor to every pie.
Since 2000, it has been a significant part of the Sheboygan food scene.
The pizza here uses slow-fermented dough and fresh Wisconsin mozzarella. They also offer air-shipped Bufala mozzarella for a rich taste. San Marzano tomatoes, grown near Mount Vesuvius, enhance the quality of their sauce.
Il Ritrovo focuses on seasonal and sustainable ingredients. Their dedication to Italian methods ensures a true Neapolitan experience.
This pizzeria is one of the few in the U.S. certified by the Vera Pizza Napoletana.
You can enjoy a meal in a cozy setting, making it perfect for dining with friends or family. Its reputation is built on quality and authenticity, attracting many pizza lovers.
Rating: 4.7 (1300 reviews)
Location: 515 S 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Contact: (920) 803-7516
Website: Visit Website
3) Moosejaw Pizza & Dells Brewing Co.
Source: Moosejaw Pizza & Dells Brewing Co. Instagram
Moosejaw Pizza & Dells Brewing Co. is known for its handcrafted pizzas and fresh ingredients. The dough is made daily, ensuring a great taste in every slice.
The menu also includes burgers, pastas, and sandwiches, making it a perfect spot for varied tastes.
This family-friendly restaurant features a large arcade and fun antler accessories for kids. The All-You-Can-Eat Breakfast Buffet is a highlight, offering popular items like breakfast pizzas, omelets, and pancakes.
It’s available daily during the summer and on weekends during the off-season.
The brewpub offers a selection of microbrews on tap, showcasing local flavors. Visit the second floor to see the brewing process in action.
Moosejaw also provides classic sodas on tap, adding variety for those who prefer non-alcoholic options.
Whether you’re stopping by for breakfast, lunch, or dinner, you can expect a lively atmosphere.
Large groups are welcome, making it a great choice for gatherings or celebrations. Reservations are not taken, but flexibility is key for enjoying your visit.
Rating: 4.3 (7000 reviews)
Location: 110 Wisconsin Dells Pkwy S, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
Contact: (608) 254-1122
Website: Visit Website
4) Santino’s Little Italy
Source: Santino’s Little Italy Instagram
Santino’s Little Italy offers a genuine taste of Italian cuisine right in Milwaukee. You can expect a focus on fresh and locally sourced ingredients.
This includes high-quality flour and cheese, which enhance the flavor of each dish.
The restaurant is known for its authentic pizzas, crafted with care. They use Caputo 00 flour and Grande mozzarella for a truly Italian taste. You can also enjoy the rich flavor of San Marzano tomatoes in their sauces.
In addition to the delicious food, Santino’s has a welcoming atmosphere. You can find patio seating available, making it a great spot for dining outside.
The location is near Barnacle Buds, another local favorite.
Reservations are highly recommended here, as it gets busy. Whether you’re looking for a quick bite or a special meal, Santino’s Little Italy won’t disappoint.
Rating: 4.8 (1300 reviews)
Location: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Contact: (414) 897-7367
Website: Visit Website
5) Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant
Source: Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant Instagram
Wells Brothers Italian Restaurant has a rich history dating back to 1921. Founded by James and Dominic Wells, it started in Racine and has become a beloved spot in Wisconsin.
The restaurant is known for its delicious pizza, which many locals and visitors rave about. Ingredients like giardiniera add a unique twist that sets their pizza apart.
Wells Brothers also emphasizes customer experience. They have recently implemented a new reservation policy for larger groups to ensure smooth service.
With a long-standing reputation, this restaurant continues to attract pizza lovers who appreciate quality and tradition.
Rating: 4.7 (1600 reviews)
Location: 2148 Mead St, Mt Pleasant, WI 53403
Contact: (262) 632-4408
Website: Visit Website
6) Dells Pizza Lab
Dells Pizza Lab is known for its unique take on pizza. You can find a variety of flavors, including their famous Pizza Bowl Salad.
This dish offers a delightful twist that pizza lovers will appreciate.
The atmosphere is inviting, making it a great spot for families and friends to enjoy a meal together. You can even dine outside on the patio during the warmer months.
The restaurant aims to provide a fun and relaxed experience.
If you’re in a hurry, online ordering is available. You can also get delivery through popular services like DoorDash.
This makes it easy to enjoy your favorite pizza from home.
Dells Pizza Lab has received positive reviews and holds a strong reputation in Wisconsin Dells. It’s a must-visit if you’re exploring the local food scene.
Rating: 4.6 (1100 reviews)
Location: 332 State Hwy 13, Wisconsin Dells, WI 53965
Contact: (608) 253-0305
Website: Visit Website
7) Pizza Brutta
Source: Pizza Brutta Instagram
Pizza Brutta delivers authentic Neapolitan-style pizza by focusing on fresh, local ingredients. The team is dedicated to making each pizza with care, ensuring a delicious experience for you.
You can enjoy their menu, which features classic pizzas and unique options. Each dish highlights the flavors of the region, making it a great choice for pizza lovers.
They also offer catering services for events. Whether it’s a party or a gathering, Pizza Brutta will tailor the menu to fit your needs.
With a strong commitment to the local food community, Pizza Brutta is a standout in Madison’s dining scene. Make sure to check out their offerings.
Rating: 4.6 (1100 reviews)
Location: 1805 Monroe St, Madison, WI 53711
Contact: (608) 257-2120
Website: Visit Website
8) Broken Tree Pizza
Source: Broken Tree Pizza Instagram
Broken Tree Pizza is a family-owned restaurant located in downtown Neenah. Established in 2014, it specializes in wood-fired pizza with American-inspired flavors.
You can enjoy a variety of pizzas, salads, and appetizers in a casual atmosphere.
The restaurant uses fresh, local ingredients to create its menu. Popular items include unique pizzas like the Dixie Chicken and the Margherita. You can eat in or order takeout to enjoy at home.
In addition to its restaurant service, Broken Tree Pizza offers a mobile trailer. This feature lets you bring their wood-fired pizza to your special events or business gatherings.
With a strong local reputation, this pizzeria is known for its delicious food and cozy setting.
Rating: 4.6 (718 reviews)
Location: 124 W Wisconsin Ave Suite 170, Neenah, WI 54956
Contact: (920) 720-2275
Website: Visit Website
9) State Street Pizza
State Street Pizza offers a cozy atmosphere where you can enjoy handcrafted pizzas and calzones. They make their dough and sauce fresh on-site every day, ensuring a tasty meal.
The menu includes a variety of options, so there’s something for everyone.
You can choose to dine in or carry out your order. For those who prefer takeout, you can call ahead, and they will bring your food to your vehicle.
This makes it convenient for you to enjoy your meal at home or anywhere you like.
One of their notable new menu items is the house-made pork green chile bean and cheese burrito. This addition offers a delicious twist for those looking to try something different. You can also add beef or chicken to customize your meal.
State Street Pizza is open from Wednesday to Sunday, making it easy to plan your visit. They do not currently offer delivery, so keep that in mind when ordering.
Rating: 4.6 (147 reviews)
Location: 319 W State St, Fox Lake, WI 53933
Contact: (920) 928-2929
Website: Visit Website
10) Wy’east Pizza
Source: Wy’east Pizza Instagram
Wy’east Pizza is known for its dedication to crafting delicious pizzas. They use a long fermentation process for their dough, which helps create a thin crust with a puffy outer edge. This method ensures a perfect balance of crispiness and flavor in every bite.
You can enjoy your pizza in a cozy dining atmosphere or opt for takeout. To go orders are available from Wednesday to Sunday, and you can easily place them by phone.
For those preferring to dine in, it’s best to make a reservation online.
The restaurant features a straightforward ordering process. When you arrive, your order can be picked up at the counter or brought directly to your car for convenience. They prioritize customer experience, ensuring you receive confirmation messages for your orders.
Wy’east Pizza is a local favorite with a strong focus on traditional pizza-making techniques. Their commitment to quality ingredients and baking practices makes it a must-visit stop for pizza lovers.
Rating: 4.7 (430 reviews)
Location: 5601 W Vliet St, Milwaukee, WI 53208
Contact: (414) 943-3278
Website: Visit Website