Idaho offers a diverse array of sandwich shops, each providing a unique twist on this classic meal. With the state’s growing culinary scene, sandwich enthusiasts can discover local favorites that cater to a wide range of tastes and preferences.
This article explores the 10 best sandwich shops in Idaho, showcasing the culinary diversity and creativity found throughout the state.
From traditional delis to innovative gourmet options, these establishments have made a significant impact on the local dining landscape.
Readers will find recommendations that highlight quality ingredients, unique recipes, and exceptional service. This selection not only celebrates the best of Idaho’s sandwich offerings but also serves as a guide for both residents and visitors alike.
1) Best Sandwich Shack
Source: Best Sandwich Shack Instagram
Best Sandwich Shack is a notable spot in Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, attracting both locals and visitors. Famed for its diverse sandwich offerings, it provides a range of flavors and ingredients that appeal to various tastes.
The establishment has built a reputation for exceptional quality, with fresh ingredients that enhance the overall sandwich experience. Customers appreciate the attention to detail in both preparation and presentation.
The cozy atmosphere invites patrons to enjoy their meals on-site or to take them to go. Its friendly staff contributes to a welcoming environment, making it a popular choice for lunch or a quick bite.
Many people frequent Best Sandwich Shack for its consistency and delightful menu options. Each visit often promises a satisfying meal that keeps customers returning.
Rating: 4.8 (658 reviews)
Location: 518 E Best Ave, Coeur d’Alene, ID 83814
Contact: (208) 625-0629
Website: Visit Website
2) Green’s Deli
Source: Green’s Deli Instagram
Green’s Deli, located in Boise, is well-regarded for its fresh ingredients and extensive sandwich menu. The deli offers a variety of options, catering to diverse tastes and preferences. Visitors appreciate the quality of the meats, cheeses, and vegetables used in their sandwiches.
The atmosphere of the deli is welcoming, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a casual meal with friends. With efficient service, patrons can enjoy their food without long waits. The staff is known for their friendliness and knowledge about the menu.
Green’s Deli also provides online ordering options, allowing customers to conveniently place their orders through their website. This feature has been popular with those who prefer takeout or need to grab a meal on the go.
Rating: 4.9 (21 reviews)
Location: 1100 W Idaho St STE 110, Boise, ID 83702
Contact: (208) 936-0401
Website: Visit Website
3) Off Broadway Deli
Source: Off Broadway Deli Instagram
Off Broadway Deli is a family-owned establishment that prides itself on an old-fashioned approach to food and service. The staff treats customers like family, creating a welcoming atmosphere for all.
The deli offers a diverse menu featuring a wide range of sandwiches, salads, and sides. Specialties include various deli and pesto sandwiches, chicken dishes, and comforting sides like macaroni salad and fries.
They also provide discounts for Boise State or military ID holders, along with active firefighters and police officers. This exemplary service highlights their commitment to the local community.
Their menu is made fresh to order, allowing customers to choose from numerous bread types and trimmings. This customization ensures that each sandwich is tailored to individual tastes.
Rating: 4.7 (421 reviews)
Location: 3369 S Federal Way, Boise, ID 83705
Contact: (208) 385-9943
Website: Visit Website
4) Salt N’ Pepper Sandwich Co.
Source: Salt N’ Pepper Sandwich Co. Instagram
Salt N’ Pepper Sandwich Co. stands out in Hailey, Idaho, offering a menu filled with homemade sandwiches, salads, and soups. The focus on fresh, quality ingredients makes this spot a local favorite for lunch.
The shop emphasizes quick service, with each lunch accompanied by a homemade chocolate chip cookie and a dill pickle spear. In addition to lunch, they serve all-day breakfast and a variety of coffee drinks.
Customers can also indulge in sweet treats like banana cake and triple-chocolate brownies. The inviting atmosphere features a cozy interior and a beautiful back patio for outdoor dining.
Salt N’ Pepper Sandwich Co. is committed to providing a refreshing dining experience and offers online ordering, catering, and delivery.
Rating: 4.7 (118 reviews)
Location: 14 E Croy St, Hailey, ID 83333
Contact: (208) 788-8844
Website: Visit Website
5) Gandolfo’s New York Deli
Gandolfo’s New York Deli specializes in creating authentic New York-style sandwiches. Their menu features a variety of options, ensuring that there’s something for everyone. Known for fresh ingredients, the deli promises a genuine taste experience.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. The deli is designed for both dine-in and take-out, making it convenient for all preferences. Catering services are also available, accommodating group gatherings or events.
The establishment has developed a loyal customer base, thanks to its commitment to quality. With a focus on traditional recipes, it stands out among sandwich shops in the region.
Regular patrons often highlight the classic pastrami and corned beef sandwiches. Each creation showcases a dedication to flavor and customer satisfaction.
Rating: 4.7 (612 reviews)
Location: 1685 S Woodruff Ave, Idaho Falls, ID 83404
Contact: (208) 542-0027
Website: Visit Website
6) San Francisco Sourdough Eatery
San Francisco Sourdough Eatery is known for its authentic sourdough bread, a staple of its menu. This eatery prides itself on using traditional recipes that have been honed over the years. Customers enjoy the distinct flavors and textures that sourdough brings to each sandwich.
The menu features a variety of sandwich options, all made fresh to order. Popular choices include turkey, ham, and classic deli combinations. Each sandwich showcases the unique qualities of the sourdough bread, making it a standout location in the area.
In addition to sandwiches, the eatery offers soups and salads, providing a complete meal for diners. Many patrons appreciate the fast service and friendly staff, which enhances the overall dining experience.
San Francisco Sourdough Eatery’s inviting atmosphere makes it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike to enjoy a hearty meal. It has become a favored destination for anyone looking for quality sandwiches in Idaho.
Rating: 4.8 (459 reviews)
Location: 2044 S Eagle Rd, Meridian, ID 83642
Contact: (208) 888-9623
Website: Visit Website
7) MB SANDWICH HOUSE
MB Sandwich House stands out as a local favorite in Boise. Its commitment to quality and speed makes it a go-to spot for lunch. Patrons can choose from a selection of cold items or order hot sandwiches prepared to their liking.
This establishment prides itself on using locally sourced ingredients to create fresh offerings. The menu features a variety of sandwiches, including unique options like the Islander, which is noted for its flavor and quality. Customers appreciate the inviting atmosphere and the friendly service provided by staff.
The restaurant also offers a range of sides and desserts, including popular sliders and cookies. With its simple yet clean layout, MB Sandwich House ensures a pleasant dining experience. For those interested in joining the team, there are opportunities for growth and training.
Rating: 4.6 (297 reviews)
Location: 4510 W Overland Rd, Boise, ID 83705
Contact: (208) 345-6301
Website: Visit Website
8) Big Bear Deli
Source: Big Bear Deli Instagram
Big Bear Deli is known for its emphasis on fresh ingredients and hearty sandwiches. Located in Post Falls, this deli offers a menu that appeals to a wide range of tastes. Patrons can expect a friendly atmosphere in which to enjoy their meals.
The sandwiches at Big Bear Deli are crafted with care. Each option showcases a variety of meats, cheeses, and toppings, allowing customers to customize their orders to their liking. The deli is especially noted for its generous portion sizes and flavorful combinations.
In addition to the sandwiches, Big Bear Deli provides several side options, including salads and chips, making it easy to create a satisfying meal. The staff is committed to ensuring a positive dining experience, which adds to the deli’s charm.
With its high rating, Big Bear Deli has established itself as a local favorite. It combines quality food with a welcoming environment that encourages repeat visits.
Rating: 4.7 (612 reviews)
Location: 700 E 8th Ave, Post Falls, ID 83854
Contact: (208) 457-8465
Website: Visit Website
9) Midtown Deli
Midtown Deli is a notable spot for sandwich enthusiasts in Idaho. Located conveniently in Post Falls, it offers a variety of sandwich options that cater to different tastes. The menu features classic deli sandwiches prepared with fresh ingredients.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and welcoming atmosphere. Many patrons commend the attention to quality, making each visit a satisfying experience. Whether looking for a quick lunch or a leisurely meal, Midtown Deli meets those needs effectively.
The deli is well-known for its clean environment and efficient service. It has become a local favorite, drawing in both regulars and newcomers. With a strong reputation built on customer feedback, it remains a top choice in the area.
10) Fat Guys Fresh Deli
Source: Fat Guys Fresh Deli Instagram
Fat Guys Fresh Deli offers a diverse menu featuring deli-style sandwiches, soups, and salads. The emphasis on scratch-made ingredients sets it apart in the Treasure Valley.
Diners can choose from a variety of menu options or request a custom sandwich crafted to their liking.
In addition to an inviting dining experience, the deli provides catering services for various events, including weddings and office parties. Their team is experienced in catering for both large and small gatherings throughout the region.
The location is easily accessible, situated near the intersection of Overland and Eagle. Customers can enjoy a convenient pick-up option and are encouraged to explore their other Boise and Caldwell locations.
Rating: 4.5 (1100 reviews)
Location: 1626 S Wells Ave, Meridian, ID 83642
Contact: (208) 855-0424
Website: Visit Website
History of Sandwiches in Idaho
The history of sandwiches in Idaho reflects regional influences, local ingredients, and evolving culinary traditions. Understanding this history helps appreciate how these simple meals have developed in the state.
Early Beginnings
The sandwich’s roots in Idaho trace back to the early 19th century. Settlers and miners often sought quick, portable meals while working.
Bread became a staple, serving as a convenient vessel for various fillings.
Local ingredients, such as meats from ranchers and produce from farms, played a crucial role. Sandwiches often featured cold cuts, cheeses, and seasonal vegetables, representing the agricultural bounty of the region.
Additionally, early diners began to open simple shops that focused on providing these quick meals. They utilized traditional recipes while incorporating local flavors, establishing a foundation for the sandwich culture in Idaho.
Evolution of Local Recipes
As Idaho’s population grew, so did the variety of sandwiches available. The arrival of diverse cultures introduced new flavors and techniques. Immigrant communities contributed their culinary traditions, enriching the local sandwich scene.
Regional favorites began to emerge, such as the “Idaho Spud Sandwich,” which incorporates locally grown potatoes with various toppings. Delis and cafes started experimenting with unique combinations.
By the late 20th century, gourmet sandwich shops began to gain popularity, emphasizing fresh, locally sourced ingredients. This trend continues today, as artisans focus on creativity, quality, and sustainability in their sandwich offerings.
Unique Ingredients Found in Idaho Sandwiches
Idaho sandwiches often stand out due to their distinctive ingredients that reflect the region’s agricultural richness. Unique meats, breads, and spreads contribute to a culinary experience that showcases local flavors.
Locally Sourced Meats
Many sandwich shops in Idaho prioritize using locally sourced meats, such as grass-fed beef and free-range chicken. These ingredients often come from nearby farms, ensuring freshness and supporting local economies.
One popular option is hickory-smoked ham, which adds a robust flavor to various sandwich creations.
Additionally, bison meat is a favored choice, providing a leaner alternative that many sandwich enthusiasts appreciate. It often features in classic builds, allowing connoisseurs to enjoy a truly regional taste.
Regional Breads and Spreads
Bread plays a crucial role in Idaho sandwiches, with local bakeries contributing to the variety.
Many shops feature artisan breads, like sourdough and rye, which are crafted using traditional techniques. This promotes a unique texture and flavor, enhancing the sandwich experience.
Idaho also offers interesting spreads, such as huckleberry jam and local mustards.
Huckleberries, a staple berry of the region, are often incorporated into sweet or savory spreads, while regional mustards vary in spice level. These ingredients elevate the humble sandwich, making it a delightful culinary journey unique to Idaho.