Massachusetts boasts a vibrant culinary scene, with sandwich shops that offer a diverse range of options. From classic deli sandwiches to innovative creations, there is something for every palate.
Identifying the best sandwich shops in Massachusetts reveals not only popular favorites but also hidden gems that showcase local flavors.
Food enthusiasts often seek out recommendations to enhance their dining experiences. This article highlights ten exceptional sandwich shops within the state that stand out for their quality, creativity, and customer satisfaction.
Each shop has its unique offerings that contribute to the rich tapestry of Massachusetts’ sandwich culture.
1) The Linden Store
Source: The Linden Store Instagram
The Linden Store has been a beloved part of the Wellesley community since 1933. It is known for offering a variety of delicious sandwiches and homemade soups, crafted with care and fresh ingredients.
Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and friendly service that has become part of its charm.
Their menu features a range of classic and creative options, appealing to many tastes. Daily specials keep the offerings exciting, giving regular visitors something new to try.
Catering services are also available, making it a go-to spot for parties and events.
In addition to great food, The Linden Store prides itself on excellent customer service. Patrons often return not just for the sandwiches, but for the positive dining experience.
This establishment exemplifies what a great sandwich shop should be, combining quality food with a community feel.
Rating: 4.8 (324 reviews)
Location: 162 Linden St, Wellesley, MA 02482
Contact: (781) 237-9229
Website: Visit Website
2) Fat Larry’s
Source: Fat Larry’s Instagram
Fat Larry’s is a well-regarded sandwich shop located in Reading, Massachusetts. Known for its high-quality ingredients, the establishment focuses on crafting flavorful sandwiches that cater to various tastes.
The menu features a range of options, ensuring there is something for everyone.
Customers appreciate the attentive service and friendly atmosphere. The shop has built a loyal following among locals who frequently visit for lunch or a casual bite.
Many reviews highlight the freshness of the ingredients and the generous portion sizes.
In addition to its signature sandwiches, Fat Larry’s offers the option for online ordering, making it convenient for those who prefer takeout. The shop maintains a strong online presence, showcasing their offerings and specials.
The team at Fat Larry’s is committed to providing a satisfying dining experience. They ensure that each customer’s needs are met, fostering a welcoming environment for all patrons.
Rating: 4.9 (57 reviews)
Location: 169 Haven St, Reading, MA 01867
Contact: (781) 205-6128
Website: Visit Website
3) Best Sandwich Company
Source: Best Sandwich Company Instagram
Best Sandwich Company is a notable spot in Peabody, Massachusetts, well-regarded for its diverse menu. While sandwiches are a highlight, the restaurant also offers a range of other dishes, including pizza and pasta.
The establishment has built a strong reputation among locals, making it a go-to choice for many families. The casual atmosphere allows for a comfortable dining experience, whether it’s a quick bite or a family meal.
Customers appreciate the convenience of curbside pickup, which simplifies the process of enjoying a meal on the go.
Additionally, Best Sandwich Company frequently features special offers that make it easy for patrons to enjoy delicious food at a better price.
Rating: 4.8 (162 reviews)
Location: 134 Newbury St, Peabody, MA 01960
Contact: (978) 535-7000
Website: Visit Website
4) Cutty’s
Source: Cutty’s Instagram
Cutty’s has established itself as a standout sandwich shop in Brookline. Known for its high-quality ingredients, the menu features an array of sandwiches that cater to various tastes.
Each sandwich is crafted with care, emphasizing fresh produce and artisanal bread.
The atmosphere at Cutty’s is welcoming, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The staff is attentive and knowledgeable, ready to help customers choose from the diverse offerings.
In addition to sandwiches, Cutty’s offers a selection of sides and beverages, enhancing the dining experience. The shop’s commitment to quality has earned it a loyal customer base, evidenced by the numerous positive reviews.
Rating: 4.6 (472 reviews)
Location: 284 Washington St, Brookline, MA 02445
Contact: (617) 505-1844
Website: Visit Website
5) Jenny’s Place
Jenny’s Place is a highly regarded sandwich shop located in Marlborough, Massachusetts. Known for its fresh ingredients and diverse menu, it offers a variety of options that appeal to many tastes.
Customers often praise the quality of the bread and the attention given to each sandwich.
The atmosphere is welcoming, making it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors. Many patrons appreciate the friendly service that contributes to an enjoyable dining experience.
Jenny’s Place also accommodates those with dietary restrictions by providing alternatives.
Sandwich lovers can expect generous portions and unique flavor combinations at this establishment. With a focus on customer satisfaction, Jenny’s Place has built a loyal following among its patrons.
Rating: 4.9 (109 reviews)
Location: 162 Church St #2931, Marlborough, MA 01752
Contact: (774) 247-3008
6) Lucy’s Craft Deli
Source: Lucy’s Craft Deli Instagram
Lucy’s Craft Deli is known for its delicious sandwiches and commitment to quality ingredients. Located in Medford, this deli provides a cozy atmosphere for patrons looking for a satisfying meal.
The menu features a variety of sandwiches, including classic favorites and unique creations. Each sandwich is crafted with care, ensuring a delicious combination of flavors in every bite.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and the attention to detail that Lucy’s Craft Deli offers. The establishment has received positive feedback for both its food and the welcoming environment.
Rating: 4.8 (69 reviews)
Location: 472 High St, Medford, MA 02155
Contact: (781) 852-2005
Website: Visit Website
7) Billy’s Sub Shop
Source: Billy’s Sub Shop Instagram
Billy’s Sub Shop is located in the South End of Boston. It has built a reputation for serving high-quality sandwiches that locals and visitors alike enjoy.
The shop’s menu features a variety of options, showcasing fresh ingredients and classic recipes.
Open from Monday to Friday, Billy’s welcomes patrons early, starting at 6:00 AM. On Saturdays, the hours are slightly later, opening at 7:00 AM, making it a great spot for breakfast or lunch. The shop is closed on Sundays, allowing staff to rest and reload for the week ahead.
With a commitment to flavor and freshness, Billy’s Sub Shop is a favored choice for those searching for a satisfying meal. The inviting atmosphere and attentive service further enhance the dining experience.
Rating: 4.8 (535 reviews)
Location: 57 Berkeley St, 02116
Contact: (617) 426-1822
Website: Visit Website
8) Ethel & Andy’s Sandwich Shop
Ethel & Andy’s Sandwich Shop is a cherished establishment known for its family-owned atmosphere. Located in South Boston, it focuses on serving delicious breakfast and lunch options.
The shop features a menu rich in made-from-scratch items, including soups and chili. Baked goods are also prominent, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Ethel & Andy’s offers convenient pickup options and is available on popular food delivery platforms like Uber Eats and DoorDash. This accessibility enhances its appeal to busy customers.
With a commitment to quality and community, this sandwich shop stands out in the local culinary scene.
Rating: 4.8 (126 reviews)
Location: 134 K St, Boston, MA 02127
Contact: (617) 268-3027
Website: Visit Website
9) Fresser’s Delicatessen
Fresser’s Delicatessen has been a staple in Randolph since 1996. Known for its commitment to quality and customer service, it offers a wide selection of sandwiches, salads, and meals.
The shop takes pride in preparing each item to meet customers’ preferences.
This delicatessen excels in providing options for lunch and catering to holiday meals. Their menu features a variety of sandwiches made with fresh ingredients, ensuring satisfying choices for any appetite.
Delivery services enhance convenience for local patrons.
Fresser’s Delicatessen is dedicated to making every lunchtime experience enjoyable. With a welcoming atmosphere, it encourages customers to visit and explore their offerings.
Rating: 4.8 (334 reviews)
Location: 1097 N Main St, Randolph, MA 02368
Contact: (781) 961-4383
Website: Visit Website
10) Michael’s Deli
Source: Michael’s Deli Instagram
Michael’s Deli has been a staple in Brookline for nearly four decades, renowned for its authentic New York style deli offerings. The establishment is famous for its award-winning corned beef sandwich, which has garnered a loyal following.
The meats served at Michael’s are sourced from the Bronx and are prepared fresh on-site every day. Alongside sandwiches, the menu features a variety of homemade dishes, including knishes and soups, prepared from family recipes using quality ingredients.
Owner Steven Peljovich is dedicated to providing excellent food and customer service. He is recognized not only for his culinary skills but also for his involvement in local community initiatives.
Michael’s Deli has received numerous accolades, including features in respected publications and awards from Trip Advisor and Boston Magazine. The deli continues to draw customers looking for a delicious meal in a welcoming environment.
Rating: 4.6 (459 reviews)
Location: 256 Harvard St, Brookline, MA 02446
Contact: (617) 738-3354
Website: Visit Website
History of Sandwiches in Massachusetts
The sandwich has a rich history in Massachusetts, tracing back to the colonial era. Early settlers brought various European influences, leading to a blend of techniques and flavors.
In the 18th century, taverns served simple fare, often including meat between bread. This idea gained popularity among the working class, who needed convenient meals.
The term “sandwich” is attributed to John Montagu, the 4th Earl of Sandwich, in the 18th century. It is believed he ordered meat served between slices of bread to avoid interrupting gambling.
Massachusetts embraced this trend. By the 19th century, local markets and street vendors began offering assorted sandwiches.
Key sandwich styles emerged, such as the lobster roll. This dish reflects the region’s seafood heritage and has become iconic in Boston’s culinary scene.
In the modern food landscape, Massachusetts is home to many celebrated sandwich shops. They range from classic delis to innovative eateries, showcasing the evolution of sandwiches.
Popular Types of Sandwiches
Massachusetts boasts a rich variety of sandwiches that capture local flavors and traditions. Two standout options include the iconic lobster roll and the classic Italian sub, both cherished for their unique ingredients and preparation styles.
Lobster Rolls
Lobster rolls are a signature dish in Massachusetts, particularly in coastal towns. They feature succulent chunks of lobster meat, often tossed with a light mayonnaise or butter.
The filling is typically served in a toasted, buttery roll, which enhances the flavor while providing a satisfying crunch. Variations may include additional ingredients like celery for crunch or spices for depth.
Lobster rolls can be found in various locales, from upscale seafood shacks to casual diners, each offering its twist on this beloved sandwich. Fresh, high-quality lobster is essential to the experience, making this dish a must-try for seafood lovers.
Italian Subs
Italian subs are another popular sandwich, showcasing the state’s Italian heritage. These subs are typically loaded with an array of cold cuts, including salami, ham, and capicola, layered with provolone cheese.
Additional toppings often include sliced tomatoes, lettuce, onions, and a drizzle of olive oil and vinegar, enhancing the flavor profile. The use of a fresh, crusty sub roll provides the ideal vehicle for these hearty fillings.
Each shop may have its unique take, allowing for personal touches like spicy peppers or special house dressings. Italian subs are loved for their robust flavors and satisfying crunch, making them a staple in sandwich shops throughout Massachusetts.
Local Ingredients That Make A Difference
Sandwich shops in Massachusetts often stand out due to their use of fresh local ingredients, enhancing flavors and supporting regional producers. Key elements such as seafood and artisanal bread contribute significantly to the quality of offerings at these establishments.
Fresh Seafood
Massachusetts is renowned for its rich coastal waters, providing an abundance of fresh seafood. Many sandwich shops source ingredients like lobster, crab, and clams from local fishermen. This not only ensures freshness but also supports the local economy.
Lobster rolls are a particularly popular choice, showcasing the succulent sweetness of the meat. Often dressed lightly with mayonnaise and served in a toasted roll, they highlight the seafood’s natural flavors.
Other seafood options may include sandwiches featuring grilled fish, like cod or haddock, seasoned simply to enhance their taste. Locally sourced seafood elevates the dining experience and appeals to patrons seeking authentic New England flavors.
Artisanal Bread
The foundation of a great sandwich often lies within its bread.
Massachusetts boasts several artisan bakeries that create high-quality loaves using traditional methods and local ingredients.
Bakers often use regional grains, contributing to unique flavors and textures.
Options like sourdough, ciabatta, and multigrain breads are commonly found in sandwich shops across the state.
Many establishments highlight the importance of a crusty exterior combined with a soft, airy interior.
This contrast not only adds to the sandwich’s overall appeal but also helps hold the fillings securely.
Choosing artisanal bread locally produced ensures freshness and supports community businesses.