Ohio boasts a diverse culinary scene, with many local favorites that stand out. For sandwich lovers, the state offers an impressive selection of shops known for their unique flavors and quality ingredients.
Each establishment brings its own twist to classic and contemporary sandwiches, providing a delightful experience for patrons.
Exploring these sandwich shops allows one to appreciate the creativity and passion behind each creation.
From hearty deli-style options to innovative gourmet offerings, there’s something to satisfy every palate. This article highlights the ten best sandwich shops in Ohio, showcasing their signature offerings and what makes them exceptional.
1) Herb’n Twine Sandwich Co.
Source: Herb’n Twine Sandwich Co. Instagram
Herb’n Twine Sandwich Co. is recognized for its creative approach to the classic sandwich. The shop prioritizes fresh ingredients, with bread baked daily.
This commitment to quality shines through in every item on the menu.
The menu features an array of sandwiches, including innovative combinations that elevate typical flavors. Some popular items incorporate unique sauces and toppings, ensuring a satisfying experience for customers.
With a focus on carryout service, Herb’n Twine has become a go-to spot for lunch and quick meals. They encourage patrons to place large or catering orders in advance to ensure availability.
Herb’n Twine also offers a Frequent Twiners card, rewarding loyal customers with punches for their purchases. This initiative fosters a strong community around the shop and enhances customer engagement.
Rating: 4.6 (487 reviews)
Location: 4309 Lorain Ave, Cleveland, OH 44113
Contact: (216) 465-9600
Website: Visit Website
2) Katzinger’s Delicatessen
Source: Katzinger’s Delicatessen Instagram
Katzinger’s Delicatessen is a well-known sandwich shop located in Columbus, Ohio. It specializes in authentic deli-style sandwiches that reflect a commitment to quality ingredients and traditional recipes.
The shop’s atmosphere is inviting, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike.
One of the highlights of Katzinger’s is their signature Reuben sandwich, which pairs well with a selection of craft beers. A happy hour promotion offers $2 off any sandwich when a customer purchases a beer, making it an attractive option for those looking to unwind after a long day.
The deli features a wide variety of sandwiches, including vegetarian options, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy. The friendly staff is knowledgeable and always ready to help customers choose the perfect meal.
The establishment values community engagement and often hosts events that celebrate local culture, adding to its appeal in the neighborhood.
Rating: 4.5 (2400 reviews)
Location: 475 S 3rd St, Columbus, OH 43215
Contact: (614) 228-3354
Website: Visit Website
3) Potbelly Sandwich Shop
Potbelly Sandwich Shop offers a diverse menu featuring a variety of sandwiches, salads, and beverages. Customers appreciate the quality ingredients and made-to-order meals.
The casual and vibrant atmosphere provides a welcoming space for patrons to enjoy their food.
The shop is particularly known for its warm, toasted sandwiches that cater to different tastes. A selection of fresh, hearty options make it a popular choice for lunch and dinner alike. It ensures that there is something for everyone, whether one prefers meat, vegetarian, or vegan options.
Located in downtown Columbus, it attracts both locals and visitors. The convenient location enhances its appeal, making it an ideal pitstop for those exploring the area or in need of a meal during a busy day.
The friendly staff contributes to a positive dining experience, ensuring that customers feel valued. With a consistent focus on customer satisfaction and quality service, Potbelly Sandwich Shop stands out in the competitive sandwich shop landscape.
Rating: 4.1 (399 reviews)
Location: 17 S High St #175, Columbus, OH 43215
Contact: (614) 224-1976
Website: Visit Website
4) DiBella’s Subs
DiBella’s Subs is known for its fresh and satisfying sandwiches. The rolls are baked at least twice a day, ensuring each sub is made with warm, soft bread. This commitment to quality sets the foundation for their extensive sandwich menu.
The restaurant also offers catering services for various occasions, including business meetings and parties. Customers can choose from single sub trays to full catering packages, making it a convenient option for gatherings.
Gift cards are available as well, perfect for fans of DiBella’s. They can be purchased at any location or ordered online for added convenience.
Rating: 4 (593 reviews)
Location: 1539 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH 43212
Contact: (614) 291-1993
Website: Visit Website
5) Cornerstone Deli & Cafe
Source: Cornerstone Deli & Cafe Instagram
Cornerstone Deli & Cafe offers a variety of delicious sandwiches and cafe-style dishes. It is known for its welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, making it a popular spot for locals and visitors alike.
The deli prides itself on high-quality ingredients and generous portions. Customers can choose from a wide range of sandwich options, paired with fresh sides.
In addition to dine-in service, Cornerstone Deli & Cafe provides catering for events and parties. This makes it a convenient choice for gatherings or special occasions.
The restaurant also features online ordering for pickup, allowing patrons to enjoy their favorite meals without the wait.
Rating: 4.6 (897 reviews)
Location: 3296 N High St, Columbus, OH 43202
Contact: (614) 267-3354
Website: Visit Website
6) Deli-Licious
Deli-Licious is a notable sandwich shop located in Columbus, Ohio. It has gained a reputation for its fresh ingredients and expertly crafted sandwiches. Customers appreciate the variety offered, including classic deli favorites and unique specialty options.
The inviting atmosphere complements the quality of the food, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. Attention to detail is evident in each sandwich, ensuring a satisfying experience for any diner.
Deli-Licious also focuses on customer service, with staff members known for their friendliness and willingness to make recommendations. This contributes to a welcoming environment where patrons feel valued.
For those looking for a delicious meal in a casual setting, Deli-Licious stands out in Ohio’s bustling food scene.
Rating: 4.8 (386 reviews)
Location: 141 N High St, Columbus, OH 43215
Contact: (614) 621-1444
Website: Visit Website
7) Deli Ohio
Source: Deli Ohio Instagram
Deli Ohio is a popular sandwich shop located in Canton, Ohio. It is known for a wide selection of freshly made sandwiches that cater to various tastes. The shop’s welcoming atmosphere makes it a favorite spot for locals.
One of the highlights is the quality of ingredients used, which contributes to the flavorful sandwiches. Customers appreciate the range of options available, ensuring there is something for everyone. Friendly staff members add to the positive experience.
Deli Ohio operates during weekdays, providing a quick lunch option for those in the area. Its convenient location and reliable service make it an ideal choice for both takeout and dining in.
Deli Ohio maintains an impressive reputation among patrons, evidenced by numerous positive reviews highlighting their consistent quality and service.
Rating: 4.7 (439 reviews)
Location: 328 Walnut Ave NE, Canton, OH 44702
Contact: (330) 453-7777
Website: Visit Website
8) The Brown Bag Delicatessen
Source: The Brown Bag Delicatessen Instagram
The Brown Bag Delicatessen is known for its fresh ingredients and generous portions. Sandwich lovers appreciate the variety on the menu, which showcases classic deli flavors and unique creations.
The welcoming atmosphere makes it a great spot for both quick lunches and leisurely meals. Regulars often highlight the attentive service and community-focused vibe.
This eatery also features a selection of sides and beverages that complement the sandwich offerings. It is a reliable choice for families and anyone craving a satisfying meal.
Rating: 4.5 (1200 reviews)
Location: 898 Mohawk St, Columbus, OH 43206
Contact: (614) 443-4214
Website: Visit Website
9) Potbelly Sandwich Shop
Potbelly Sandwich Shop offers a variety of sandwiches that cater to diverse tastes. Customers can choose from warm and toasty options featuring fresh ingredients, including meats and vegetables, ensuring a satisfying meal.
The atmosphere inside Potbelly is casual and welcoming, making it an ideal spot for lunch breaks or casual dining. Many appreciate the friendly service that enhances the overall dining experience.
In addition to sandwiches, Potbelly also serves soups, salads, and their famous cookies, adding variety to the menu. These options cater to different dietary preferences and provide a well-rounded meal.
For those who enjoy a quick bite, Potbelly offers online ordering and delivery, allowing customers to enjoy their favorites from the comfort of home.
Rating: 4.1 (483 reviews)
Location: 1171 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH 43212
Contact: (614) 453-1116
Website: Visit Website
10) Jersey Mike’s Subs
Jersey Mike’s Subs offers a well-crafted selection of sandwiches made with high-quality ingredients. Freshly sliced meats and cheeses are combined with store-baked bread to create a flavorful experience.
Customers can enjoy their sandwiches “Mike’s Way,” which includes the addition of fresh lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil, vinegar, and spices. This preparation not only enhances the taste but also ensures each sub is made to order.
For those planning gatherings, Jersey Mike’s provides catering options. The menu includes subs by the box, subs by the bag, and personal boxed lunches, making it a convenient choice for events.
Dessert options such as cookie and brownie trays add a sweet touch to any meal. Jersey Mike’s focuses on delivering quality food with friendly service.
Rating: 4.2 (216 reviews)
Location: 7377 OH-3, Westerville, OH 43082
Contact: (614) 392-2105
Website: Visit Website
History of Sandwich Shops in Ohio
Sandwich shops in Ohio have evolved significantly over the years, influenced by both regional preferences and cultural shifts.
The history reflects the diverse culinary influences and the growing popularity of sandwiches as a convenient meal choice.
Origins and Growth
The origins of sandwich shops in Ohio can be traced back to the late 19th century. Initially, these establishments catered to workers seeking quick and affordable meals.
The industrial boom in cities like Cleveland and Cincinnati drove demand for fast and filling options.
As time passed, the sandwich gained popularity beyond the working class, becoming a staple in American dining. Ohioans embraced local favorites, with innovations like the “Ohio-style” sandwich featuring unique ingredients such as coleslaw and French fries.
The emergence of local chains and mom-and-pop shops throughout the 20th century further solidified the sandwich’s place in Ohio’s food landscape.
Cultural Influence
Sandwich shops in Ohio have played a vital role in reflecting the state’s diverse cultural heritage. Various immigrant groups, including Italian, Greek, and German communities, introduced unique flavors and recipes, enriching the sandwich scene.
Notable examples include the Italian sub, featuring meats and cheeses imported from Italy, and the classic Reuben sandwich, believed to have origins linked to the Jewish immigrant community.
In recent years, health trends have influenced sandwich offerings, with shops incorporating fresh, local ingredients.
Artisan bread, gourmet toppings, and plant-based options have emerged, catering to a broad spectrum of tastes. This adaptability highlights how sandwich shops continue to thrive while embracing Ohio’s rich cultural tapestry.
Regional Variations in Sandwich Offerings
Ohio’s diverse culinary landscape influences its sandwich offerings. Each region features unique flavors and ingredients that reflect local tastes and traditions.
Northern Ohio Specialties
In Northern Ohio, sandwiches often showcase the region’s rich agricultural products and cultural influences.
A popular choice is the Cleveland-style corned beef sandwich, typically piled high with tender, spiced meat.
Another regional favorite is the Polish boy, originating from the city of Cleveland. This sandwich consists of a kielbasa sausage served on a bun, topped with coleslaw, French fries, and a zesty barbecue sauce.
Additionally, sourdough bread is a staple in many local delis, adding a distinct tang to various sandwich creations.
Northern Ohio’s sandwich shops emphasize flavor and hearty portions, catering to a diverse palate.
Southern Ohio Delights
Southern Ohio focuses on comfort food in its sandwich offerings, often with a hearty, rustic touch.
The Ohio-style BBQ pulled pork sandwich stands out, featuring slow-cooked pork smothered in tangy barbecue sauce, served on soft buns.
Another favorite is the Cincinnati-style chili sandwich, where chili is layered on top of a bun and often garnished with cheddar cheese and onions. This sandwich offers a unique burst of flavor, reflecting the region’s eclectic culinary history.
Hoagies and sub sandwiches are also prevalent, filled with a variety of meats, cheeses, and fresh vegetables.
Southern Ohio’s sandwich offerings emphasize warmth and satisfaction, catering to local preferences.