Wisconsin is known for its rich culinary landscape, and sandwich shops play a significant role in that tradition. The state offers a diverse selection of establishments that cater to various tastes, making it a haven for sandwich lovers.
From classic delis to modern eateries, there is an abundance of options available, showcasing local ingredients and creative recipes.
This article explores ten of the best sandwich shops across Wisconsin, highlighting what makes each one unique.
Whether seeking a hearty meal or a quick snack, readers will discover places that offer exceptional flavors and satisfying experiences.
1) Scungilli’s Sandwich Shop
Source: Scungilli’s Sandwich Shop Instagram
Scungilli’s Sandwich Shop is a renowned establishment in Rochester, Wisconsin, known for its quality sandwiches and friendly service. This local gem has garnered a loyal following for its fresh ingredients and unique flavor combinations.
The atmosphere is casual, making it an inviting spot for both regulars and newcomers.
Visitors can expect a diverse menu featuring classic and inventive sandwich offerings. The shop emphasizes quality, sourcing ingredients that enhance the taste and overall experience.
Signature items often stand out and showcase the creativity of the kitchen.
In addition to sandwiches, Scungilli’s offers a selection of sides and beverages that pair well with their main offerings. This attention to detail ensures that every meal feels complete.
The staff prides itself on providing excellent customer service, further enhancing the dining experience.
The shop has established itself as a must-visit for sandwich lovers in the area, making it a noteworthy stop for anyone exploring Wisconsin’s culinary landscape.
Rating: 5 (123 reviews)
Location: 207A W Main St, Rochester, WI 53167
Contact: (262) 661-6503
Website: Visit Website
2) Sandwich Sisters
Sandwich Sisters is a charming sandwich shop located in Eagle, Wisconsin. Owned by sisters Ann and Emma, the establishment focuses on providing fresh, high-quality deli-style sandwiches.
Their menu features a wide variety of options, catering to different tastes and preferences.
The sisters pride themselves on using bread that is baked daily, ensuring freshness in every bite. In addition to sandwiches, they offer seasonal soups and chili, along with snack options like chips.
Weekly specials keep their menu exciting for regular customers.
For those planning events or gatherings, Sandwich Sisters provides party platters, making it easy to serve delicious food to guests.
The warm, welcoming atmosphere reflects their passion for both food and community.
Rating: 4.9 (19 reviews)
Location: 101 S Rd, Eagle, WI 53119
Contact: (262) 441-7062
Website: Visit Website
3) The Sandwhich Shop
The Sandwhich Shop is a standout destination for sandwich lovers in Wisconsin. It features a diverse menu with a variety of unique and classic sandwich options. The focus on fresh ingredients sets it apart from other local establishments.
Customers often highlight the quality and flavor of the sandwiches. The casual atmosphere welcomes patrons, making it an ideal spot for a quick lunch or a leisurely meal.
Friendly staff members contribute to a pleasant dining experience. The shop’s dedication to customer service enhances its reputation as a local favorite.
Frequent visitors appreciate the consistent quality and generous portions offered at The Sandwhich Shop. It’s a place where anyone can savor a satisfying meal.
Rating: 4.8 (243 reviews)
Location: 511 S Water St, Sparta, WI 54656
Contact: (608) 487-3489
Website: Visit Website
4) Megawich – The Ultimate Sandwich
Source: Megawich – The Ultimate Sandwich Instagram
Megawich is known for its diverse menu offering a wide variety of sandwiches that cater to different tastes. This sandwich shop takes pride in using fresh ingredients and unique combinations to create flavorful options.
Customers appreciate the inviting atmosphere of the establishment, making it a great place to enjoy a meal.
The shop features both classic favorites and innovative creations, appealing to both traditional and adventurous eaters.
Their sandwich selection includes options for meat lovers, vegetarians, and those seeking gluten-free choices. This variety ensures that there is something for everyone to enjoy.
Megawich also offers catering services, making it a popular choice for events and gatherings. With a focus on quality and customer satisfaction, it has become a notable destination for sandwich enthusiasts.
Rating: 4.8 (712 reviews)
Location: 1426 E Brady St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Contact: (414) 488-9420
Website: Visit Website
5) Hot Lunch
Source: Hot Lunch Instagram
Hot Lunch is a popular spot in Madison, known for its impressive sandwich offerings. The menu features a range of creative and satisfying options, catering to various tastes and dietary preferences. Fresh ingredients and bold flavors are hallmarks of their sandwiches.
The casual atmosphere makes it a great place for a quick lunch or a relaxed meal with friends.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and the attention to detail in each dish. Regulars often highlight the daily specials, which showcase unique combinations.
Conveniently located, Hot Lunch attracts both locals and visitors. Its reputation for quality and consistency has earned it a loyal following in the community.
Rating: 4.9 (227 reviews)
Location: 708 1/4 E Johnson St, Madison, WI 53703
Contact: (608) 405-5566
Website: Visit Website
6) Hen’s Deli
Source: Hen’s Deli Instagram
Hen’s Deli is a well-regarded sandwich shop located in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. Known for its quality ingredients, the deli offers a variety of sandwiches that cater to different tastes and preferences.
Customers appreciate the fresh meats and locally sourced products used in their creations.
The atmosphere of Hen’s Deli is casual and inviting, making it a great spot for a quick lunch or a leisurely meal with friends and family. The staff is friendly and attentive, contributing to a positive dining experience.
This deli has garnered a loyal following, with many regulars returning to try new offerings or enjoy their classic favorites. The menu often features daily specials, adding variety and excitement for patrons.
Regularly mentioned in reviews, the quality of the sandwiches and the service stands out. Hen’s Deli has become a popular choice among locals seeking a satisfying meal.
Rating: 4.9 (128 reviews)
Location: 209 W Florida St, Milwaukee, WI 53204
Contact: (414) 935-2287
Website: Visit Website
7) Merton Sub Co
Merton Sub Co is a highly regarded sandwich shop located in Hartland, Wisconsin. Known for its fresh ingredients and variety of subs, it has built a loyal customer base.
The menu features a range of options, from classic Italian to specialty subs. Each sandwich is made to order, ensuring quality and flavor with every bite.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and cozy atmosphere, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. The shop often receives positive feedback for its consistent quality and inviting environment.
Merton Sub Co also offers takeout options, accommodating those on the go. It stands out as a go-to place for delicious sandwiches in the area.
Rating: 4.9 (96 reviews)
Location: W282 N7134 Main St, Hartland, WI 53029
Contact: (262) 538-0919
Website: Visit Website
8) Casetta Kitchen and Counter
Source: Casetta Kitchen and Counter Instagram
Casetta Kitchen and Counter is a standout in Madison for sandwich lovers. They offer a range of specialty sandwiches, made with sliced-to-order deli cuts and homemade toppings.
Their bread is freshly baked, providing a perfect base for each flavorful creation.
The restaurant’s menu allows patrons to either choose from their specialties or customize their own sandwiches. This flexibility is appealing for those seeking a personalized dining experience.
In addition to their delicious sandwiches, Casetta also offers a catering service. This is ideal for group lunches, as the catering menu features large-format salads, deli sides, and sandwich boxes.
For dessert, they include homemade chocolate chip cookies, adding a sweet touch to any meal. Casetta Kitchen and Counter effectively combines quality, variety, and convenience in its offerings.
Rating: 4.8 (448 reviews)
Location: 222 W Washington Ave Ste 30, Madison, WI 53703
Contact: (608) 467-8108
Website: Visit Website
9) Nice Sandwich
Source: Nice Sandwich Instagram
Nice Sandwich is a popular eatery located in West Allis, Wisconsin. Known for its fresh and healthy offerings, the menu features a variety of sandwiches, pizzas, and wraps. The restaurant prides itself on using only the freshest ingredients for their meals.
Customers frequently commend the size and quality of the sandwiches. The bread is reported to be particularly fresh, and patrons appreciate the reasonable pricing. This combination makes it a go-to spot for those looking for a satisfying meal.
In addition to dine-in and takeout options, Nice Sandwich also provides catering services. They are equipped to handle catering for various occasions, ensuring that events can feature their delicious offerings.
Samantha B. from Yelp expresses her enthusiasm, stating that everyone should try Nice Sandwich to see what they are missing. The strong community support further highlights its standing as a local favorite.
Rating: 4.7 (286 reviews)
Location: 2705 S 108th St, West Allis, WI 53227
Contact: (414) 541-8877
Website: Visit Website
10) Fat Mama’s Po Boyz and Sandwiches
Fat Mama’s Po Boyz and Sandwiches is a popular destination in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, known for its vibrant atmosphere and delicious offerings. The restaurant specializes in American cuisine, particularly sandwiches and po’ boys, that delight patrons’ taste buds.
This eatery operates four days a week, ensuring that customers can satisfy their cravings during lunch and dinner hours. With a focus on quality ingredients, the menu offers a variety of options that appeal to different palates.
The staff prides itself on friendly service, creating a welcoming environment. Carryout and delivery options are available, making it convenient for those who prefer enjoying meals at home.
The restaurant enhances the local dining scene with its commitment to great food and customer satisfaction.
Rating: 4.9 (316 reviews)
Location: 616 Ohio St, Oshkosh, WI 54902
Contact: (920) 385-4654
Website: Visit Website)
History of Sandwiches in Wisconsin
Wisconsin’s sandwich history reflects its rich cultural tapestry.
From early settlers to contemporary culinary trends, sandwiches have evolved and adapted to local preferences and ingredients.
Origins and Evolution
The roots of sandwiches in Wisconsin can be traced back to European immigrants in the late 19th and early 20th centuries.
German, Polish, and Italian settlers introduced various bread and meat combinations that formed the basis of many favorite local sandwiches.
The Reuben, a blend of corned beef, sauerkraut, Swiss cheese, and rye bread, is a notable creation linked to Jewish delis.
Over time, regional ingredients like cheese and bratwurst became staples, leading to unique creations such as the Wisconsin cheese sandwich.
These sandwiches reflect both tradition and local agriculture, showcasing Wisconsin’s identity.
Cultural Influences
The cultural influences on Wisconsin’s sandwich scene are diverse. The state is known for its cheese production, which has been a game-changer for sandwich variations.
Restaurants often incorporate local dairy products into their offerings, enhancing flavors and drawing on Wisconsin’s agricultural heritage.
Additionally, the influx of immigrants influenced sandwich styles. The blending of culinary traditions resulted in unique dishes like the Italian beef sandwich and spicy bratwurst sandwiches, popular at local festivals.
These cultural contributions have helped shape the sandwich landscape in Wisconsin, making it a focal point of culinary exploration.
Wisconsin’s Unique Sandwich Ingredients
Wisconsin’s culinary scene boasts distinct ingredients that elevate its sandwiches.
Notably, local cheeses and regional meat varieties contribute richness and flavor that reflect the state’s heritage.
Local Cheeses
Wisconsin is renowned as “America’s Dairyland,” offering an impressive array of cheeses, perfect for sandwich creation.
Varieties like Cheddar, Monterey Jack, and Swiss are popular choices.
- Cheddar: Known for its sharp flavor, aged Cheddar adds depth to sandwiches. It pairs well with meats and can be melted for added richness.
- Colby Jack: This semi-soft cheese blends Colby and Monterey Jack, offering a creamy and mild taste, ideal for layering in a sandwich.
- Brick Cheese: A specialty of the state, it has a nutty flavor and is excellent when grilled.
These cheeses not only enhance taste but also reflect Wisconsin’s dairy traditions.
Regional Meat Varieties
Wisconsin’s sandwich scene is complemented by a variety of local meats that add unique flavors.
Many shops feature meats sourced from nearby farms, ensuring freshness.
- Summer Sausage: Often seasoned with various spices, this cured meat is a popular sandwich filler, providing a savory, tangy bite.
- Braunschweiger: A liver sausage that is rich and spreadable, it adds a distinct taste to cold sandwiches.
- Smoked Ham: Locally smoked ham incorporates regional flavors, perfect for hearty sandwiches topped with local pickles and spreads.
These meats not only celebrate Wisconsin’s agricultural heritage but also enhance the regional sandwich experience.