Wyoming is home to a diverse array of culinary delights, and sandwich shops are no exception.
Food enthusiasts eager to find the best places to enjoy a delicious sandwich can explore these top-rated spots across the state.
From classic deli sandwiches to unique local creations, these establishments offer something for everyone.
Whether one is a resident or just passing through, discovering quality sandwich shops can enhance the dining experience.
Wyoming’s sandwich scene reflects the state’s rich culture and flavors, providing options that cater to various tastes and preferences.
1) 2nd Street Deli
Source: 2nd Street Deli Instagram
2nd Street Deli is a popular spot in Laramie, known for its commitment to quality and freshness. The deli is locally owned and prides itself on using hand-selected ingredients for all its menu items.
Customers can expect friendly service from the staff, who take orders at the counter.
Meals can be enjoyed either on-site or taken to go, which adds convenience for those on a busy schedule.
The deli also offers a selection of draft beers, making it an inviting place for both a quick bite or a relaxed meal.
The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for anyone looking to enjoy a good sandwich in town.
Rating: 4.9 (109 reviews)
Location: 123 E Ivinson Ave, Laramie, WY 82070
Contact: (307) 742-7046
Website: Visit Website
2) Saratoga Sandwich Company
Saratoga Sandwich Company is known for its fresh and delicious breakfast and lunch offerings. The establishment prides itself on using high-quality ingredients, including Boar’s Head meats and cheeses, along with local produce whenever available.
Customers can enjoy a variety of options, from handcrafted sandwiches to salads and soups.
The menu emphasizes speed and convenience, allowing patrons to order ahead or dine in without long wait times.
The welcoming atmosphere is supported by friendly staff who are eager to assist with orders.
The company values community engagement and aims to create an enjoyable dining experience for both locals and visitors.
For coffee lovers, Cowbell Coffee operates within the sandwich shop, offering a full premium barista line to complement meals.
Rating: 4.7 (279 reviews)
Location: 104 W Bridge Ave, Saratoga, WY 82331
Contact: (307) 326-5555
Website: Visit Website
3) Choppers Deli
Choppers Deli is a renowned spot in Sheridan, Wyoming, beloved for its artisanal sandwiches. The deli stands out with a commitment to fresh ingredients and flavorful combinations that keep customers coming back.
The menu features a variety of options that cater to different tastes.
From classic deli sandwiches to unique creations, there is something for everyone. Each sandwich is crafted with care, ensuring a satisfying experience.
The welcoming atmosphere makes it a great place to grab a quick lunch or enjoy a relaxed meal.
The staff is known for their friendliness and efficient service, adding to the positive dining experience.
Patrons frequently highlight the quality of the food and the creativity of the options available. This dedication to excellence has earned Choppers Deli a loyal following in the local community.
Rating: 5 (37 reviews)
Location: 1514 E 5th St, Sheridan, WY 82801
Contact: (307) 672-5963
Website: Visit Website
4) The Wild Lunch Market
The Wild Lunch Market offers a unique dining experience in Casper. It is known for its fresh ingredients and creative sandwich options. Each sandwich is crafted with care, making it a favorite among locals.
Diners appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff.
The market emphasizes quality and flavor, ensuring every visitor enjoys their meal. It’s an ideal spot for a quick lunch or a leisurely afternoon bite.
With a focus on seasonal produce, the menu reflects local flavors.
Signature creations often highlight unique combinations that surprise and delight patrons. This dedication to creativity keeps the offerings fresh and exciting.
Many customers recommend trying a variety of sandwiches to fully experience the menu.
The Wild Lunch Market is not just a place to eat, but a place to savor and enjoy good food.
Rating: 4.9 (44 reviews)
Location: 124 E 2nd St, Casper, WY 82601
Contact: (307) 262-6587
Website: Visit Website
5) The Breadboard
The Breadboard is a well-regarded sandwich shop located in Buffalo, Wyoming. Known for its diverse menu, it offers a variety of freshly made sandwiches that cater to different tastes and dietary preferences. The establishment prides itself on using quality ingredients, contributing to the satisfaction of its customers.
This popular spot attracts both locals and visitors alike.
With a focus on customer service, the staff is friendly and attentive, creating an inviting atmosphere. The shop is often praised for its cleanliness and efficient service, making it a pleasant place to enjoy a meal.
In addition to sandwiches, The Breadboard serves various sides and beverages, allowing for a complete dining experience. Diners can appreciate the cozy setting while savoring their meals.
Rating: 4.6 (496 reviews)
Location: 190 E Hart St, Buffalo, WY 82834
Contact: (307) 684-2318
Website: Visit Website
6) Steamboat Deli & Outlet
Source: Steamboat Deli & Outlet Instagram
Steamboat Deli & Outlet is a notable spot in Casper, Wyoming, known for its inviting atmosphere and diverse menu. This deli offers a variety of sandwiches made with fresh ingredients, catering to different tastes and dietary preferences.
Customers appreciate the quality of the meats and cheeses used in their sandwiches.
The options range from classic favorites to unique creations, ensuring there is something for everyone.
In addition to sandwiches, Steamboat Deli & Outlet also features delicious sides and drinks. The combination of tasty food and friendly service makes it a popular choice among locals and visitors alike.
Visitors can enjoy their meals in a casual setting, making it a convenient stop for lunch or a quick snack while exploring the area.
Rating: 4.6 (134 reviews)
Location: 251 S Center St, Casper, WY 82601
Contact: (307) 333-6557
Website: Visit Website
7) 381 Subs and Salads
381 Subs and Salads is a family-owned eatery located in downtown Riverton, Wyoming. It specializes in a range of delicious hot and cold subs, salads, soups, and more. The restaurant also features a convenient drive-thru, perfect for those on the go.
Customers can enjoy a variety of options, including ice cream, shakes, and floats. Both alcoholic and non-alcoholic beverages are available, catering to diverse tastes. 381 Subs prides itself on using real ingredients for a satisfying dining experience.
The inviting atmosphere makes it a great spot for dining in, while the drive-thru offers quick service for customers looking to take their meals with them. Each dish is crafted to deliver flavor and quality, ensuring that guests leave happy.
Rating: 4.7 (42 reviews)
Location: 702 E Main St, Riverton, WY 82501
Contact: (307) 463-7594
Website: Visit Website
8) The Breadboard
The Breadboard is a well-regarded sandwich shop located in Riverton, Wyoming. Known for its hearty sandwiches and fresh ingredients, it attracts locals and visitors alike. The menu features a diverse selection of sandwiches, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a relaxed meal.
Customers appreciate the friendly service and quick turnaround, allowing them to enjoy their food without a long wait.
In addition to sandwiches, The Breadboard offers various sides and beverages to complement any meal. This commitment to quality and service has garnered it a loyal following in the community.
The shop’s convenient location makes it an easy stop for those traveling through Riverton or visiting the area.
Rating: 4.5 (259 reviews)
Location: 124 E Washington Ave, Riverton, WY 82501
Contact: (307) 856-7044
Website: Visit Website
9) Smiling Moose
Smiling Moose is a popular sandwich shop known for its welcoming atmosphere and variety of menu options. Patrons can expect a range of deli-style sandwiches crafted with fresh ingredients. The shop emphasizes quality, ensuring that each selection meets customer expectations.
The menu caters to diverse tastes with classic favorites and unique creations.
Customers appreciate the generous portion sizes and the option to customize their sandwiches. In addition to sandwiches, Smiling Moose offers sides and beverages to complement meals.
Located in Gillette, Wyoming, this deli has become a favored spot for locals and travelers alike. The convenient location makes it an easy stop for those exploring the area.
With a steady flow of customers and positive feedback, Smiling Moose continues to thrive in the competitive food scene of Wyoming.
Rating: 4.2 (457 reviews)
Location: 2711 S Douglas Hwy Suite A, Gillette, WY 82716
Contact: (307) 363-4104
Website: Visit Website
10) New York City Sub Shop – Jackson Hole
New York City Sub Shop in Jackson Hole has been a staple since 1985. Founded by Bruce Tlougan, it initially operated from a small storefront, accommodating just three customers.
The focus was on delivering high-quality sandwiches quickly and affordably.
In 2000, the shop relocated to its current location on North Jackson Street. This site provides ample indoor seating and convenient parking, making it more accessible to customers.
The interior features vibrant murals painted by artist Greta Gretzinger, adding a unique charm to the dining experience. The shop has maintained its commitment to quality and service throughout its three decades of operation.
With a diverse menu, it continues to attract both locals and tourists. New York City Sub Shop is known for its delicious sandwiches and welcoming atmosphere.
Rating: 4.4 (335 reviews)
Location: 20N S Jackson St, Jackson, WY 83001
Contact: (307) 733-4414
Website: Visit Website
History of Sandwich Shops in Wyoming
The evolution of sandwich shops in Wyoming reveals a rich narrative tied to local culture and food trends. From humble origins to modern establishments, these shops reflect the state’s unique history and community.
Early Beginnings
In the late 19th century, Wyoming’s settlers relied on simple, hearty meals that could be prepared efficiently. Sandwiches became a popular choice due to their portability and ease of preparation.
Small cafes and diners emerged in towns like Cheyenne and Laramie, serving basic sandwiches made from local ingredients such as beef and bread.
The rise of railroads in the early 20th century expanded access to varied foods, influencing menu options at these dining spots. As Wyoming’s population grew, so did the diversity of sandwich offerings, with Eastern European immigrants introducing recipes like the Reuben.
These early establishments laid the groundwork for the sandwich culture in the state.
Modern Developments
The latter half of the 20th century marked significant growth in the sandwich industry across Wyoming. As the state urbanized, sandwich shops evolved to include a variety of international influences. Fast-casual dining, specializing in gourmet sandwiches, began to flourish.
Today, local shops use farm-to-table concepts, showcasing Wyoming’s agricultural bounty. Ingredients like bison, artisan cheeses, and seasonal vegetables are commonly featured.
The emergence of food trucks also contributed to the popularity of sandwiches, offering creative options at events and festivals, further enriching the sandwich landscape in Wyoming.
Popular Sandwich Ingredients
Sandwiches often feature a mix of fresh ingredients that elevate their taste and appeal. Key components include locally sourced produce and flavors that highlight regional cuisine.
Locally Sourced Produce
Locally sourced produce plays a crucial role in enhancing sandwich quality. Ingredients such as crisp lettuce, ripe tomatoes, and fresh herbs contribute to flavor and texture.
- Lettuce Varieties: Crisp romaine or vibrant arugula can add crunch.
- Tomatoes: Heirloom tomatoes offer a burst of flavor.
- Herbs: Fresh basil or cilantro can elevate a simple sandwich.
Many sandwich shops prioritize these ingredients, supporting local farmers and ensuring freshness. This commitment to sourcing can lead to a more sustainable dining experience.
Regional Flavors
Regional flavors often define the character of sandwiches.
- Bison: Ground bison or bison pastrami provides a rich taste.
- Cheeses: Local cheeses like aged cheddar or blue cheese enhance flavor profiles.
- Spices: Using local spice blends can add depth and uniqueness.
These elements not only satisfy taste buds but also provide an authentic sense of place. This makes each bite a reflection of Wyoming’s gastronomic identity.