If you love Italian food, Wisconsin has plenty to offer. This list highlights the ten best Italian restaurants in the state, ensuring you’ll find delicious dishes regardless of your location.
From classic pasta to unique twists on traditional recipes, these restaurants serve something for everyone.
Each restaurant has its own charm and specialties, making them worth a visit. Whether you’re looking for a cozy dinner spot or a place to celebrate a special occasion, you’ll discover many options to satisfy your Italian cravings.
1) Safina
Source: Safina Instagram
Safina offers a true taste of Sicily. The restaurant focuses on creating a dining experience that feels like a family gathering.
The warm atmosphere invites you to enjoy delicious Italian dishes with loved ones.
The menu features high-quality ingredients prepared with care. You can expect authentic flavors and a variety of options that showcase Italy’s rich culinary tradition.
Safina is dedicated to excellent service and ensuring that every guest feels welcomed.
Private events can be hosted at Safina, making it an ideal spot for celebrations of all sizes. Whether you are planning a small gathering or a larger party, they cater to your needs.
With its commitment to affordable prices and consistent quality, Safina stands out among Italian restaurants in the area.
Rating: 4.8 (155 reviews)
Location: 785 N Jefferson St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Contact: (414) 488-9578
Website: Visit Website
2) Zarletti
Source: Zarletti Instagram
Zarletti is a fine dining restaurant that brings northern Italian cuisine to downtown Milwaukee. Since its opening in 2004, it has gained a reputation for its flavorful dishes inspired by traditional recipes.
The chef draws from lessons learned in his grandmother’s kitchen and his travels throughout Italy.
You can enjoy an array of homemade desserts and imported wines that enhance the dining experience. The restaurant offers a warm atmosphere, perfect for a special night out or a casual meal.
Curbside service is available most days, making it convenient for those who prefer to enjoy their meals at home. For a sit-down dining experience, the restaurant offers evening service on weekdays and later hours on weekends.
With its commitment to quality and authentic flavors, Zarletti stands out among Italian establishments in Wisconsin.
Rating: 4.6 (668 reviews)
Location: 741 N Milwaukee St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Contact: (414) 225-0000
Website: Visit Website
3) Stella Van Buren
Source: Stella Van Buren Instagram
Stella Van Buren is a key player in Milwaukee’s dining scene. This restaurant blends Italian and American flavors to create a unique experience.
Its modern design enhances the vibrant atmosphere, making it a great spot for any occasion.
You can enjoy a range of delicious dishes, from housemade pastas to premium cuts of beef. The menu offers something for everyone, ensuring a satisfying meal whether you’re having a casual dinner or a special celebration.
Stella Van Buren also features a private dining area for gatherings. The restaurant hosts events and special promotions, which makes each visit exciting and fresh.
This place stands out for its creativity and attention to detail. You’ll find it a welcoming spot to unwind and savor thoughtfully prepared meals.
Rating: 4.6 (1,100 reviews)
Location: 550 N Van Buren St, Milwaukee, WI 53202
Contact: (414) 847-5622
Website: Visit Website
4) Osteria Papavero
Source: Osteria Papavero Instagram
Osteria Papavero offers a casual Italian dining experience in downtown Madison. The restaurant is known for traditional dishes with a modern twist.
Chef Francesco Mangano, hailing from Bologna, showcases local ingredients in his cooking.
You can enjoy various daily specials featuring fresh vegetables and proteins sourced from nearby farms. This focus on local food enhances the dining experience.
Whether you prefer indoor dining, takeout, or delivery, Osteria Papavero has options to suit your needs.
The restaurant also hosts special events and pop-ups, usually on Sundays when they are typically closed. You can join their mailing list to stay informed about these unique offerings.
Rating: 4.6 (561 reviews)
Location: 128 E Wilson St, Madison, WI 53703
Contact: (608) 255-8376
Website: Visit Website
5) Santino’s Little Italy
Source: Santino’s Little Italy Instagram
Santino’s Little Italy stands out for its commitment to quality. They use fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring that every dish is flavorful.
The restaurant prides itself on using high-quality items like Caputo 00 flour, Grande mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes.
You can enjoy a meal on their patio, which adds to the dining experience. The setting is vibrant and inviting, perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion.
Reservations are recommended, as this popular spot tends to fill up quickly.
Finding Santino’s is easy since it’s on the same street as the well-known Barnacle Buds. The convenient location makes it a great choice whether you’re a local or just visiting Milwaukee.
Rating: 4.8 (1300 reviews)
Location: 352 E Stewart St, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Contact: (414) 897-7367
Website: Visit Website
6) Calderone Club – Downtown Milwaukee
Source: Calderone Club – Downtown Milwaukee Instagram
Calderone Club is a well-known Italian restaurant located in downtown Milwaukee. It has been a favorite for many years, serving authentic Italian dishes in a welcoming atmosphere.
People appreciate the blend of quality food and good service.
The restaurant offers a diverse menu, featuring classic Italian cuisine. You can expect to find dishes that highlight traditional recipes made with fresh ingredients.
The ambiance adds to the dining experience, making it a popular choice before events like concerts.
Many guests rate their experiences highly, praising both the food and the location. Calderone Club’s central position makes it easy to visit before heading to shows or other downtown activities.
Whether you’re a local or a visitor, this restaurant is worth trying for a genuine Italian meal.
Rating: 4.5 (1300 reviews)
Location: 842 N Old World 3rd St, Milwaukee, WI 53203
Contact: (414) 273-3236
Website: Visit Website
7) Carmella’s an Italian Bistro
Source: Carmella’s an Italian Bistro Instagram
Carmella’s an Italian Bistro offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for dinners with family or friends. The restaurant is known for its authentic Italian dishes that highlight fresh ingredients and rich flavors.
You can enjoy a variety of pasta dishes, pizzas, and traditional Italian specialties.
The bistro focuses on providing excellent customer service. The staff is friendly and aims to make your dining experience enjoyable.
You can expect to be welcomed with a smile and receive attention to your needs throughout your meal.
Carmella’s is open from Tuesday to Saturday, 3 PM to 9 PM. This schedule makes it easy to plan your visit for dinner. Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.
Rating: 4.7 (1000 reviews)
Location: 716 N Casaloma Dr, Appleton, WI 54913
Contact: (920) 882-4044
Website: Visit Website
8) Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993
Source: Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993 Instagram
At Ristorante Bartolotta dal 1993, you can enjoy authentic Italian cuisine in a warm and inviting atmosphere. The restaurant focuses on dishes inspired by the Valle d’Aosta region of Italy.
This culinary journey showcases traditional flavors and fresh ingredients.
The dining experience is available daily from 5 PM to 9 PM. You can also join Bartolotta Rewards for added benefits, making your meals even more enjoyable.
They offer various events throughout the year, such as wine and beer dinners, which highlight the best of Italian dining. It’s a great way to explore different wines paired with delicious dishes.
If you’re looking for a memorable night out, consider making a reservation. With several convenient parking options nearby, your visit will be hassle-free.
Rating: 4.5 (592 reviews)
Location: 7616 W State St, Wauwatosa, WI 53213
Contact: (414) 771-7910
Website: Visit Website
9) Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant
Source: Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant Instagram
At Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant, you will experience a blend of tradition and authenticity. The restaurant opened in 2002 and quickly built a reputation for serving delicious Italian food.
The recipes come from family traditions, featuring classic dishes made with fresh ingredients.
The menu highlights homemade pasta and sauces, all crafted using local produce. You can expect to find a variety of options that showcase true Italian flavors.
Wine plays an important role in Italian dining, and Tenuta’s offers a diverse selection. The staff is knowledgeable and ready to help you choose the perfect pairing for your meal.
Whether you prefer something familiar or want to try something new, you will find it here.
Tenuta’s Italian Restaurant has earned recognition as a top dining destination in the area. You will enjoy the warm atmosphere and excellent service while savoring each bite.
Rating: 4.7 (1300 reviews)
Location: 2995 S Clement Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207
Contact: (414) 431-1014
Website: Visit Website##
10) Il Ritrovo
Source: Il Ritrovo Instagram
Il Ritrovo is a standout Italian restaurant located in Sheboygan. It has been serving delicious wood-fired pizza since 2000.
This place is known for its commitment to authentic Neapolitan pizza. The restaurant uses slow-fermented dough and fresh mozzarella daily.
You can also find air-shipped Bufala mozzarella and San Marzano tomatoes on their menu. These ingredients help create a rich, flavorful pizza experience.
Il Ritrovo is one of the few Certified Vera Pizza Napoletana pizzerias in the United States. They focus on blending seasonal and sustainable ingredients with traditional Italian techniques.
If you are looking for a genuine taste of Italy, Il Ritrovo is a place you should not miss.
Rating: 4.7 (1300 reviews)
Location: 515 S 8th St, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Contact: (920) 803-7516
Website: Visit Website
Italian Culinary Traditions
Italian cuisine is rich in history and flavor. It focuses on simple ingredients and traditional practices, leading to delicious and memorable dishes.
Freshness and seasonality are key themes that define this culinary style.
Key Ingredients in Italian Cuisine
Italian cooking heavily relies on high-quality, fresh ingredients. Here are some common staples:
- Olive Oil: Used for cooking and dressings, it adds depth and flavor.
- Tomatoes: Fresh or canned, they are essential for sauces, salads, and many dishes.
- Cheese: Varieties like Parmigiano-Reggiano and mozzarella enhance flavor and texture.
- Pasta: The heart of many meals, made from flour and water, comes in numerous shapes and sizes.
- Herbs: Basil, oregano, and rosemary are crucial for seasoning.
These ingredients form the foundation of many iconic dishes. The importance of local variations adds to the diversity of flavors found across Italy.
Importance of Freshness and Seasonality
Freshness is essential in Italian cuisine. Chefs focus on seasonal produce to ensure optimal flavor and quality.
In addition to taste, seasonal ingredients often support local farming. This practice ensures that restaurants serve dishes that reflect the best of what’s available.
Dishes change with the seasons, offering unique creations throughout the year. Tomatoes shine in summer, while root vegetables are perfect for winter meals. By using what is fresh and in season, you can enjoy a taste of Italy that feels vibrant and alive.
Exploring Regional Italian Dishes
Wisconsin offers a wide variety of Italian dishes that reflect the rich regional diversity of Italy. Each area has its unique flavors and cooking styles, which you can enjoy at local Italian restaurants.
Northern Italian Specialties
Northern Italy is known for dishes that focus on creamy sauces, rich cheeses, and fresh ingredients.
Popular examples include Risotto, a creamy rice dish cooked slowly with broth. It often features ingredients like mushrooms, saffron, or seafood.
Polenta is another favorite, made from cornmeal and served soft or allowed to cool and sliced. This staple often accompanies meat dishes.
You might also find Pesto, a vibrant sauce made from basil, garlic, pine nuts, and Parmesan cheese. It’s commonly tossed with pasta or used as a dip. Northern Italian meals often incorporate seasonal vegetables and are less reliant on tomato-based sauces than their southern counterparts.
Southern Italian Fare
Southern Italian cuisine is characterized by its bold flavors and use of fresh tomatoes, olive oil, and herbs.
One famous dish is Pizza Napoletana, a thin, wood-fired pizza topped with tomatoes, mozzarella, and fresh basil.
Another classic is Pasta alla Norma, made from eggplant, tomatoes, and ricotta salata. This dish showcases the region’s love for rich vegetable flavors.
Seafood dishes, like Spaghetti alle Vongole (spaghetti with clams), highlight the region’s coastal influences.
You’ll also find Arancini, fried rice balls filled with meat or cheese, as a popular appetizer.
Southern Italian dishes often reflect a rustic, hearty style that brings out the best of their ingredients.